Wanted to touch on the hype surrounding Bryce Harper and put to black and white my prediction of what will happen with him.
For those of you not familiar with him, a recent Sports Illustrated article was written on the phenomenon that is Bryce Harper. I attached a link to the article to see what the hype is about (click on Title "Bryce Harper" for link). The article is billed as "Baseball's LeBron".
In a nutshell, he's from Las Vegas, 16 and just completed his Sophomore year of high school. He's big, strong and very talented. I believe they have him listed as 6'3", 205 and claims he throws 96 mph. His main position is catcher. After reading the article, it wouldn't be a surprise if he also parted the Red Sea and walked on water.........
In the story, they talk about how he's dominated at every level he's ever been in, never challenged, hits long home runs and is a man playing among children. There's even talk by his parents of him getting his GED, leaving school and entering the professional ranks early. Thought this would be a good time to shed some light on some of the Paul Bunyan stories....
1) HR Derby - The article mentions how he was in an international home run hitting contest last year at Tropicana Field and hit a 502 foot home run and being awarded the Babe Ruth Award for hitting the longest home run. A quick google search showed that's correct, but what the SI article fails to mention is not only did Harper NOT win the contest, he actually came in 5th. I feel sorry for the 4 guys that finished in front of him that got zero mention (including Christian Walker from Pennsylvania who won......). Here's a link to that write up: http://www.mister-baseball.com/europeans-add-power-showcase-hr-derby-resume/
2) High School Domination - The SI article mentions how his parents feel he needs to be challenged and may leave high school early in order to turn pro quicker. I looked up his stats on Max Preps and was shocked, SHOCKED, to discover he wasn't THAT dominate.... He had a very good year, especially for a Sophomore, but in reading the article, I was expecting him to have Bobby Stahel stats...... (inside joke, another Nevada Sophomore who had an incredible season, yet never gets mentioned......). The Las Vegas Wildcats were a better than average team, making the state tournament but being eliminated in the first round. Here's Harpers stats from the season: .569 batting average, .689 OBP, 3 HR's, 22 BB, 26 RBI's and 12 Doubles. Great stats, no doubt, but not Paul Bunyanesce...... The argument I hear is he was pitched around and I'm sure he was to an extent. The 22 walks were a lot, but someone else on the team had 15 walks and someone else 13. He also led the team in average and OBP and tied for the lead in HR's and doubles. He was second in RBI's. Here is the link to Max Preps if you want to look over his season stats: http://tinyurl.com/m353vz
As a comparison, here are Bobby Stahel's stats for the season. .762 batting average, .814 OBP, 5 HR's, 29 BB's, 56 RBI's and 12 Doubles. Here's the Max Prep link: http://tinyurl.com/nnohk7
Stahel is also a Sophomore catcher in Nevada, maybe he should be the "LeBron of Baseball"!
3) Pro Prospect - He's a talent. I'm not saying he's not, but lets realistically look at his potential to become a pro player. I'm on record saying if he ever makes "The Show" it'll be as a pitcher, not a position player. I'm not sure how tall his parents are or other family members, but if he's just 16 and already 6'3", I gotta think he's not done growing and has 2"-4" still to go.... If he ends up 6'7", he'll have a hard time hitting at that height. His strike zone will be too big for professional major league hitters to exploit. There have been very few successful major league hitters ever at that height. Dave Winfield was 6'6" and obviously great but who else? Richie Sexson had a nice couple of years but is no longer in baseball and I believe he was listed at 6'8". There's a reason most of the best hitters of all time were 6'2" and under. Certainly at 6'7", Harper will never be a catcher at that size. Now there have been many successful pitchers at that height and that's why I feel if he's ever able to make it to the major leagues, it'll be as a pitcher.
By the way, this is not the first time I'd heard of Bryce Harper. His name has been out there for a few years and the talk has started to take on a legend of it's own.
I'm not knocking the boy. From everything I've read and heard, he seems like a good kid and his parents just want what we all want for our kids, which is happiness and success in life. I just feel this is an instance where the media takes a story or rumor and runs with it. They see a chance to build someone up and make them larger than life.
I wish Harper well and hope he is successfull, but let's be realistic and let him enjoy being a kid. That age is tough enough as it is without national media attention focused on you. His next 5 years are going to be under a microscope.
I'm sure we'll all follow him but when he doesn't turn out to be the next LeBron, don't call him a failure. Maybe, if he's lucky, he'll be the next "Stahel"!
Bill